Skip to main content

Allow me to start with a warning: I’m not a food expert. What I do know something about is research into human psychology. And that research always shows that food is something very intuitive. I’d like to take you inside the human brain to explain what all this means.

In the spotlight: Maarten Boudry, philosopher of science and thinker on progress

The human brain is actually an organ that enables us to navigate our environment and protect ourselves from recurring dangers. It works in a very specific way, and that’s exactly what makes it so fascinating.

One of the mechanisms our brain is guilty of is essentialism: we tend to divide the world into fixed categories. When we let young children leaf through picture books about animals, they assign each animal very intuitively to one category. If you show a toddler a picture of piglets suckling from a tiger, they’ll classify them as piglets. Suckling doesn’t turn them into tiger cubs. This pigeonhole thinking is what creates resistance to Darwin’s theory of evolution. We can’t step over certain barriers, and we struggle with new (intermediate) forms because they don’t fit into our traditional classification.

On top of that, we also face moral resistance to crossing those traditional boundaries. Anyone who violates those categories provokes disgust. Just think of genetically modified food, which we naturally resist. This essentialism also comes with the associations we make. For example, everything that’s natural is also good. Organic, biological, ecological or holistic: we don’t always know the difference between these concepts, but we perceive them all as positive, because they’re natural. That’s a curious observation, because in pre-modern societies, the early inhabitants of our planet knew all too well that nature wasn’t all that positive. The harshness and wildness of nature very often kept our ancestors firmly grounded.

In fact, our modern society has gradually become estranged from nature; we tend to over-romanticise it. We have a very romantic image of farming, while it actually hasn’t been natural for a long time. On the contrary, over time we’ve domesticated every crop, bent it to our will, and we want to keep out all natural pests.

Eating meat is deeply rooted in our thinking. It triggers strong emotions that even translate into new words. ‘Meat hunger’ is one of them.

As a result, eating meat has become the cultural norm. What’s more, the richer a society becomes, the more meat it eats. So the prediction is that in the future, more meat will actually be eaten in parts of the world such as Africa and Asia.

On the other hand, we see that more and more people feel morally uneasy about consuming living beings. One survey produced some striking results:

  • 49% of people support a ban on intensive livestock farming
  • 47% of respondents would be in favour of a ban on slaughterhouses
  • No fewer than 33% of people support a ban on all forms of livestock farming

If these figures reflected reality, it would lead to worldwide veganism and the end of meat. In reality, our resistance is nowhere near that high, but the results do show our moral unease about eating meat.

And yet we see meat as something very natural. Even if development were suddenly to move extremely fast, we wouldn’t immediately embrace lab-grown meat. Because we see it as something irrational and new, while many people suffer from what we call neophobia: the fear of anything new. It’s known that, as children, we’re open to new tastes between the ages of two and four; after that, the door closes…

On the other hand, there’s also such a thing as transgenerational neophobia: within a single lifetime we undoubtedly have a lot of resistance to new food, but not across generations. If we look at what we eat today, our diet is completely different from that of our ancestors. So over generations, we do eventually come to see new things as natural. In that sense, you could say the outlook isn’t so bad after all for new developments in food.

No, I don’t have a crystal ball that gives me a clear view of the year 2040. But I suspect that meat might well go the same way as other sectors. Thanks to progress, in the furniture industry we’re increasingly choosing the convenience and ingenuity of IKEA. But at the same time, the wealth of our society is also creating a growing demand for handcrafted furniture. You see the same pattern in fashion. We wholeheartedly embrace the benefits of fast fashion, but at the same time we increasingly value well-made, tailored pieces.

That’s how I see the future of our meat too. Perhaps we’ll soon fall back on easier and more efficient techniques to make sausages, for example. But we’ll also attach more and more importance to real meat as a kind of luxury product. Because real meat speaks to our deepest intuitions: we have a universal longing for what’s natural and authentic, and not for anything processed, artificial and fake.

Technology may well lead to radical innovations, but authenticity will always remain intuitive…

“EATING MEAT IS DEEPLY ROOTED IN OUR THINKING. ONE BOLIVIAN PEOPLE HAS EVEN DEVELOPED A SEPARATE WORD FOR IT: EYEBASI, OR MEAT HUNGER.”